This is the 3rd time I've been to this place and I still don't know what to make of it. It seems at times there's 2 kitchen or 2 cooks--some times the plates are plated like your contemporary modern restaurant and other times it's rustic home cooking (one whole spatchcock on a plate ).
Mother in law was in mood for Italian though to be honest I'm not sure she knows what Italian food is beyond Dolmio pasta sauce. Sure we could have gone to Enotecca but Tartufo is easier to park and possibly more 'homely' in style and thus more acceptable incase she's not as in the mood for Italian as she thought.
I'm not Italian, have not been to Italy so am not the best judge on authenticity. But, if showcasing flavour of produce is a pillar of Italian cooking then this place is definitely legit. None of the dishes are complicated (or at least appeared to be) but everything matched together on the plate. I couldn't speak for dishes that I didn't try i.e. the ocean trout and salmon (ordered by mother in law who once again went on a rant about too much protein, meat etc) but what I did have-- everything else pictured was fantastic--you get what you see--meaty beef, sharp parmesan cheese, bitterness from the rocket and generous generous olive oil.
The special entree with the tomato etc may not seem like much but tomato was sweet without too much acidity, cheese was creamy and rich and the balsamic intense syrupy and very very balsamic.
The scampi linguine had loads of butter and have the potential to be serious comfort food. Pasta was perfect-- nice spring, texture and not all strands identical--it's the imperfections that make it seem deliciously home made.
That steak--cooked perfectly and I don't care what anyone says about ordering specials (how its the stuff they can't sell) , I would make this a regular menu item. Looking around, most tables had at least one steak.
Staff have been trained well to clear tables, pour drinks , recommend wines, entertain, befriend. So although it was a busy night there was no lax in service. Our waiter was the highlight of my mother in law (and my night)--charmed her with his accent, devoted attention to her. Thanks mate, whoever you are, so I didn't have to deal with her. You deserve the $20 tip.
It's easy to see why Tartufo has been one of the mainstays of the Emporium complex while so many of its neighbours moved on or gave up.
![]() |
carpaccio di manzo (beef carpaccio) |
![]() |
Special of the night--mozarella like cheese (forgot name) with tomato and balsamic |
![]() |
crudo di trota (I think?) deep sea ocean trout filled with scallops |
![]() |
salmon all'insalata--gravalax of salmon and blood orange |
![]() |
special of the night--scotch villet with rocket salad |
![]() |
scampi linguine |
![]() |
tiramisu |
![]() |
cheese board |